“Life is Great. Cheese makes it better.” -Avery Aames
Catalogue
To Place an Order: Call/Text +1(608)219-9579
or email at Overthemooncheese@gmail.com
Cheesemakers are listed in alphabetical order
Carr Valley Cheese
Ask about pricing on 12/5oz cases of exact weight retail cuts
Sheep Milk Cheeses
Ba Ba Blue $11.05/lb 6 lb wheel
Ba Ba Blue Smoked $12.30/lb 6 lb wheel
Black Sheep Truffle $15.05/lb 12 lb wheel
Blazing Sheep $12.90/lb 10 lb wheel
Boozin' Ewe $11.90/lb 10 lb wheel
Dancing Sheep Fontina $11.05/lb 10 lb wheel
Marisa $10.80/lb 10 lb wheel
Marisa, aged $11.95/lb 10 lb wheel
Marisa, cave aged $14.05/lb 10 lb wheel
Marisa, smoked $11.20/lb 10 lb wheel
Native Sheep $11.30/lb 12 lb wheel
Native Sheep, Smkd $12.85/lb 12 lb wheel
River Bend Sheep $12.45/lb 10 lb wheel
Sante $14.05/lb 10 lb wheel
Sheep Feta $12.55/lb 2/5 lb loaf
Goat Milk Cheeses
Bandaged Billy $14.55/lb 12 lb wheel
Baraboo Blue $12.30/lb 10 lb wheel
Billy Blue $12.30/lb 6 lb wheel
Billy Blue, smoked $13.55/lb 6 lb wheel
Black Goat Truffle $13.70/lb 12 lb wheel
Goat Bread Cheese $10.15/lb 14/10oz case
Cardona $11.55/lb 10 lb wheel
Cardona, aged $12.70/lb 10 lb wheel
Cardona, cave aged $14.75/lb 10 lb wheel
Cardona, Cocoa $13.10/lb 10 lb wheel
Cardona, Vanilla $12.60/lb 10 lb wheel
Chevre au Lait (Young Gouda) $11.80/lb 10 lb wheel
Goat Feta $10.90/lb 2/5 lb loaf
Goat Cheddar $10.55/lb 12 lb wheel
Goat Cheddar, aged $12.50/lb 12 lb wheel
Goat Cheddar, apple smoked $11.15/lb 12 lb wheel
Goat Curd $10.90/lb 2-5 lb bags
Goat Gouda $11.75/lb 10 lb wheel
Snow White Cheddar (cave aged) $12.95/lb 12 lb wheel
River Bend Goat $12.95/lb 10 lb wheel
Mixed Milk Cheeses
Airco (smoked) $14.05/lb 10 lb wheel
Benedictine $13.30/lb 10 lb wheel
Bessie’s Blend $12.05/lb 10 lb wheel
Canaria $12.35/lb 10 lb wheel
Gran Canaria $14.85/lb 10 lb wheel
Mellage $11.55/lb 10 lb wheel
Mellage, cave aged $15.95/lb 10 lb wheel
Mellage, Caso Bolo $14.75/lb 4 lb ball
Menage $11.55/lb 10 lb wheel
Mobay $12.60/lb 10 lb wheel
Shepherd’s Blend $11.55/lb 10 lb wheel
Cow’s Milk Cheddars
Curd $5.70/lb 2/5lb bag
Mild Cheddar $6.35/lb 5 lb loaf
Med Cheddar $6.55/lb 5 lb loaf
1 year Cheddar $6.90/lb 5 lb loaf
2 year Cheddar $7.55/lb 5 lb loaf
2 year Cheddar, white smoked $8.90/lb 5 lb loaf
3 year Cheddar $8.35/lb 5 lb loaf
4 year Cheddar $9.45/lb 5 lb loaf
5 year Cheddar $10.15/lb 5 lb loaf
6 year Cheddar $11.90/lb 5 lb loaf
8 year Cheddar $16.20/lb 5 lb loaf
10 year Cheddar $17.30/lb 5 lb loaf
12 year Cheddar $19.10/lb 5 lb loaf
Apple Smoked Cheddar $9.35/lb 12 lb wheel
Apple Smoked Garlic Cheddar $8.70/lb 12 lb wheel
Beer Cheddar $7.35/lb 5 lb loaf
Cave Aged Cheddar $12.50/lb 12 lb wheel
Cranberry Cheddar $9.35/lb 5 lb loaf
Chipotle Cheddar $8.45/lb 12 lb wheel
Garlic Cheddar $6.75/lb 5 lb loaf
Horseradish Cheddar $9.45/lb 5 lb loaf
Cow’s Milk Cheeses
Bread Cheese $8.05/lb 14/10oz case
(plain, garlic, jalapeno, chipotle, pizza, bacon)
Double Gloucester $7.05/lb 2/5 lb loaf
Colby $6.55/lb 2/5 lb loaf
Creama Kasa $8.90/lb 7 lb wheel
Creama Kasa, smkd $10.05/lb 7 lb wheel
Feta $7.25/lb 2/5 lb loaves
Fontina $6.70/lb 10 lb wheel
Fontina, Aged $8.35/lb 10 lb wheel
French Fontina $8.55/lb 10 lb wheel
Fontina, smoked $7.85/lb 10 lb wheel
Fontina de Provence $7.85/lb 10 lb wheel
Glacier Blue $6.80/lb 6 lb wheel
Glacier Blue Crumbles $6.10/lb 5 lb bag
Glacier Smoked Blue $7.90/lb 6 lb wheel
Glacier Smoked Blue Spruce $7.90/lb 6 lb wheel
Glacier Wildfire Blue $7.65/lb 6 lb wheel
Gorgonzola $6.80/lb 6 lb wheel
Gorgonzola Crumbles $6.10/lb 5 lb bag
Penta Creme Blue $6.90/lb 6 lb wheel
Gouda $6.90/lb 10 lb wheel
Gouda, aged $8.45/lb 10 lb wheel
Gouda, Reserve $8.55/lb 10 lb wheel
Gouda, smoked $7.90/lb 10 lb wheel
Havarti $6.90/lb 12 lb wheel
Hot Pepper Jack $6.55/lb 2/5 lb loaf
Smoked Pepper Jack $7.70/lb 2/5 lb loaf
Maustoner $8.45/lb 10 lb wheel
Monastery $7.70/lb 10 lb wheel
Monterey Jack $6.20/lb 2/5 lb loaf
Port Salue $9.80/lb 4 lb wheel
Red Abbot $9.70/lb 10 lb wheel
Sid's Bahl Baby Swiss $7.80/lb case of (6) 2 lb balls
Sid's Bahl Baby Swiss, smkd $8.90/lb case of (6) 2 lb balls
Swedish Farmer’s $7.95/lb 10 lb wheel
Butters
Cow Butter $45.00/case of 12/8oz $105.00/(2)9 lb pails
Goat Butter $60.00/case of 12/8oz $160.00/(2)9 lb pails
Sheep Butter $80.00/case of 12/8oz
Menage Butter $55.00/case of 12/8oz $155.00/(2)9 lb pails
Spreads
Parmesan $52.00/case 12/8oz
Gouda $52.00/case 12/8oz
Aged Asiago $48.00/case 12/8oz
Brew Masters Pub $48.00/case 12/8oz
Chunky Blue $48.00/case 12/8oz
Garlic $48.00/case 12/8oz
Hickory Smoked $48.00/case 12/8oz
Horseradish $48.00/case 12/8oz
Hot Habanero $48.00/case 12/8oz
Jalapeno $48.00/case 12/8oz
Late Harvest Wine $48.00/case 12/8oz
Sharp Cheddar $48.00/case 12/8oz
Southern Pimento $48.00/case 12/8oz
Spicy Beer $48.00/case 12/8oz
Swiss Almond $48.00/case 12/8oz
Toasted Onion $48.00/case 12/8oz
Cedar Grove Cheese
Plain, WI
All Cedar Grove Cheese is free of added rBGH/rBST.
40 lb block 5 lb loaf 1 lb piece
Colby $3.70/lb $4.70/lb $4.85/lb
Marble Colby $3.75/lb $4.75/lb $4.90/lb
Mild Cheddar $3.75/lb $4.75/lb $4.90/lb
Farmer (reduced fat/salt) $4.05/lb $5.05/lb $5.20/lb
Monterey Jack $3.70/lb $4.70/lb $4.85/lb
Pepper Jack $3.80/lb $4.80/lb $4.95/lb
CHEESE CURDS 20 lb 10 lb 5 lb 12 oz bag
White/yellow curds $4.00/lb $4.05/lb $4.10/lb $3.40/ea Flavored or mixed curds* $4.15/lb $4.20/lb $4.25/lb $3.55/ea
Prices above may fluctuate with the CME market price
SPECIALTY CHEESE 40 Lb 5 Lb 1 Lb
Medium Cheddar, yellow & white $5.55/lb $6.55/lb $6.70/lb
Sharp Cheddar, yellow & white $6.05/lb $7.05/lb $7.20/lb
X-Sharp Cheddar, yellow & white $6.55/lb $7.55/lb $7.70/lb
Butterkase $4.60/lb $5.60/lb $5.75/lb
Cheddar w/one flavor* $5.75/lb $6.75/lb $6.90/lb
Cheddar w/ two flavors* $5.95/lb $6.95/lb $7.10/lb
*Tomato/basil, garlic/dill, garlic, onion/chive, caraway, jalapeno, veggie, horseradish, dill 8oz pieces – Add $.50 to 1 lb price
Mozzarella (whole milk) $4.90/lb $5.90/lb $6.05/lb
Mozzarella – Fresh curd $5.25/lb 10 lb bag
Muenster $4.60/lb $5.60/lb $5.75/lb
Havarti $4.90/lb $5.90/lb $6.05/lb
Super Hot Jack $5.20/lb $6.20/lb $6.35/lb
Faarko – sheep/cow blend $12.30/lb
Specialty Wheels
10 lb wheel ½ wheel
Donatello – Aged sheep $14.40/lb $14.55/lb
Montague – Mild cow/sheep blend $12.30/lb $12.45/lb
Fleance – Sheep milk similar to Spanish Manchego $12.30/lb $12.45/lb
Capriko – Cow/goat blend $10.60/lb $10.75/lb
Goat Cheddar $10.60/lb $10.75/lb
Sheep Feta $9.40/lb (5# Loaves)
CERTIFIED ORGANIC CHEESE (certified by OCIA)
The organic milk from Cedar Grove Cheese comes from certified organic farms. By avoiding harmful chemicals, herbicides, pesticides, antibiotics and added hormones, organic dairies help preserve our earth. These cheeses are made the traditional way, without genetically modified ingredients.
40 lb block 5 lb loaf 1 lb piece
White Cheddar, mild $4.95/lb $5.85/lb $6.60/lb
White Cheddar, medium $5.20/lb $6.10/lb $6.85/lb
White Cheddar, sharp $6.95/lb $7.85/lb $8.60/lb
White Cheddar, x-sharp $7.15/lb $8.05/lb $8.80/lb
White Colby $5.10/lb $6.00/lb $6.75/lb
Monterey Jack $5.05/lb $5.95/lb $6.70/lb
Pepper Jack $5.20/lb $6.10/lb $6.85/lb
Muenster $5.45/lb $6.35/lb $7.10/lb
Mozzarella $5.05/lb $5.95/lb $6.70/lb
Unpasteurized Cheddar, Sharp $6.75/lb $7.65/lb $8.40/lb
8oz pieces – Add $1.00/lb to 1 lb price
Clock Shadow Creamery
Milwaukee, WI
Signature Fresh/Soft Cheeses
Quark – A traditional German soft cheese made from cow milk. Creamy and spreadable. Can be used as a cream cheese or ricotta style cheese. Great in desserts or flavored for dips or spreads.
$4.95/lb (Bulk weight – 3 lb bag)
$3.40/8oz tub
Chevre
$6.50/lb (Bulk weight – 5 lb bag)
$4.00/8oz tub
Fresh Curd (large cut) –
$4.85/lb (10 lb bulk weight)
$3.90/ 12 oz bag
Goat Curd
$8.25/lb (20 lb bulk weight)
Signature Block Cheeses
40 lb block 5 lb loaf 8oz pcs
Double Cream Colby $6.60/lb $7.65/lb $8.50/lb
Queso Menonita – melting cheese $6.55/lb $5.50/lb
Coalho Brazilian Grilling cheese $5.50/lb $6.55/lb
Hook’s Cheese
*Other ages and varieties available by request, lead times may apply
Aged Cheddar –
5 Lb Loaf
1 year $6.75/lb
3 year $7.75/lb
5 year $8.75/lb
10 year $18.75/lb
Pepper Jack $6.25/lb
Muenster $6.25/lb
Sheep and Goat milk Cheeses
Duda Gouda (aged sheep Gouda) $11.95/lb 7 lb wheel
Triple Play $10.95/lb 5 lb loaf
(Alpine style cow, sheep and goat)
Hurdy Gurdy (goat milk Alpine-style) $10.95/lb 5 lb loaf
Galway Bay (goat dry Jack) $10.95/lb 5 lb loaf
Goat Pepperjack $10.95/lb 5 lb loaf
Hook’s Retail Cuts
*Lead times may apply
1 lb 8 oz
Colby $6.00/lb $6.70/lb
Monterey Jack $6.00/lb $6.70/lb
Brick $6.00/lb $6.70/lb
Muenster $6.00/lb $6.70/lb
Farmer's $6.00/lb $6.70/lb
Marble Jack $6.00/lb
Dill Jack $6.00/lb
Garlic Cheddar $6.00/lb
Pepper Jack $6.00/lb $6.70/lb
Garlic Onion Jack $6.00/lb
Pesto Jack $6.00/lb
Garlic Dill Jack $6.00/lb $6.70/lb
Sun-dried Tomato Basil $6.00/lb
Bacon Cheddar $6.00/lb
Smoked Cheddar $6.00/lb
Mild Cheddar $6.00/lb
Med Cheddar $6.25/lb
Maple Jack $7.50/lb
Truffle Cheddar $12.20/lb
Swisses
Baby Swiss $7.50/lb
1 yr Swiss $8.50/lb
2 yr Swiss $9.00/lb
3 yr Swiss $11.50/lb $12.20/lb
4 yr Swiss $13.50/lb $14.20/lb
5 yr Swiss $14.50/lb $15.20/lb
Blues
Original Blue $8.70/lb
Blue Paradise $8.70/lb
Gorgonzola $8.70/lb
Little Boy Blue $12.40/lb
Barneveld Blue $10.40/lb
Ewe Calf to be Kidding $11.40/lb
Landmark Creamery
Paoli, WI
Lush sheep milk and buttery grass-fed cow milk are used to carefully create unique cheeses the represent the terroir of Southern Wisconsin. Landmark Creamery works with farmers to build sustainable, family-run dairies that support the local economy in Southern Wisconsin.
Pecora Nocciola: This sheep milk cheese won a ribbon at the 2016 American Cheese Society competition. It's firm, very nutty and grates beautifully. It, also, makes an excellent addition to a cheeseboard.
10 lb wheels $15.50/lb
Anabasque: A washed-rind sheep milk cheese, inspired by Ossau Iraty. It has a pretty orange white rind with flavor that is fruity and earthy. 2019 US Cheese Championship Gold medal winner!
9 lb wheels $16.00/lb
Pipit: A smooth and creamy sheep milk table cheese that melts beautifully. It's sweet, with an interesting finish.
5 lb loaf $14.50/ lb
Tallgrass Reserve: Made exclusively from pasture-grazed cows. It's natural moldy rind gives way to a golden, buttery interior that is creamy, grassy and complex.
10 lb wheels for $13.50/lb
Brebis: A fresh, spreadable sheep milk cheese. (Delivered frozen) Great in desserts and spreads.
5 lb bags $14.50/lb
Taleggio: A sheep milk creamy, semi-soft, washed-rind cheese. Mild flavor with a pungent aroma.
3 lb wheels $16.00/lb
Rebel Miel A beer washed, semi soft cheese with fruity, boozy notes
2.5 lb wheels $15.50/lb
Roelli Cheese-
Shullsburg, WI
Dunbarton Blue- $14.10/lb
Red Rock- $12.10/lb
Reserve Cheddar- $12.10/lb
Misc. Cheese Co.
*Price may fluctuate with market
Schroeder Kase– Rewey, WI Small Batch without fillers.
Triple Cream Brie – 6/8 oz wheels $42.00/case
Triple Cream Brie with Ash – 6/8 oz $45.00/case
Roth Kase- Monroe, WI
Buttermilk Blue – 6 lb wheel $8.75/lb
Canela (formerly Gran Queso)- 6 lb wheel $10.00/lb
Grand Cru Gruyere – 7 lb loaf $9.65/lb
Havarti – 9 lb loaf $6.55/lb
Kindred Smoked Gouda – 6 lb horn $6.10/lb
Moody Blue (smoked) $9.25/ 6lb wheel
Silver Lewis- Monticello, Wi
Muenster- $4.45/lb
Breaded Muenster Curd- $5.60/lb
Chalet Cheese (formerly Deppeler) – Monroe, WI
Swiss (mild, small eyes) $5.70 lb /6lb loaf
Sartori – Plymouth, WI
Parmesan 5 lb ¼ wheel
Bellevitano, flavored 5 lb ¼ wheel
Sarvecchio Parmesan 5 lb ¼ wheel
Regal Blend Shred (Parm, Asiago, Romano blend) 3 lb bag
Klondike – Monroe, WI
Feta – 9 lb pail in brine $35.00/pail *
Grande - Fond du Lac, Wi
Whole Milk Mozzarella
Provonello
50/50 Blend (Mozz and Provolone)
Westby Creamery – Westby, WI
Cottage Cheese, 4% $18.25/5 lb
Sour Cream $15.75/5 lb
Uplands Cheese
Pleasant Ridge Reserve is an artisanal farmstead cheese made from the unpasteurized, hormone-free milk of their herd of Wisconsin cows, fed and managed using natural “old world” practices. The cows graze lush pastures from early spring through fall, yielding milk with varied and subtle flavors and excellent nutritional value. The flavors of the pasture grasses, herbs, wildflowers and clovers are detectable in the cheese.
Similar to French Gruyeres, Pleasant Ridge Reserve is superb for cooking and can be used in soups, fondues, gratins and omelets.
Rush Creek is produced only in the fall, as the diet of the cows begins to change from summer pasture to the winter’s dry hay. This rich milk is perfect for a cheese like Rush Creek, so soft and decadent that it’s often referred to as savory custard. Each cheese is wrapped in spruce bark, which gives shape to the cheese and imparts a subtle woodsy flavor.
Availability of Rush Creek is from late October thru December, but usually sells out. Pre-orders are recommended.
Whole wheels (approx 8 -10 lbs) $14.50/lb
Cut & Vacuum-wrapped pieces $17.00/lb
Extra Aged wheels $18.50/lb
Rush Creek – 1 case/8/12 oz wheel $17.50/Wheel
Blakesville Creamery
*Coming Soon*
*Subject to change based on market price